I was living in Sussex a few moons ago and I was always slightly disorientated. Partly because the roads needed to meanander around waterways, topography etc but also because the road corridor in the area was planted with exactly the same plantings over and over again.
The design rationale appeared to me to be ‘screen the road from everyone and lets not think how we are going to acheive this screen. Roll out the next 5 miles of woodland hedge ‘.
Many town bypasses appeared the same as well – there is practically no difference in the landscaping between the bypass of East Grinstead, a town in Sussex, and the bypass to the town outside of the Rodings in Essex. Yet one is north of London and the other is south. Does this seem odd to anyone else?
Does this matter? Well yes because it could be so much better without much extra budget. The landscaping could be more interesting, varied and actually become part of the navigational structure for the road user.
Perhaps the Highway Agency has never been called to defend their design approach. Is the Highway Agency aware of what is happening in other parts of the world?
December 14th, 2009 at 9:54 am
Too Right!
We have either ‘ten boring landscape shrubs’ or ‘native flora’ both of which limit you to 10. This country is such a wasted opportunity, which i think comes back to the fact that everyone gardens at home and so is not bothered about public space. And horticulture still has a low status – as it is seen as a hobby everyone does/can do, therefore not as a skill you have to learn. So the landscape profession rarely respect the horticulturalists who are the ones who actually have the knowledge bases to do more interesting things but are never allowed to.
December 14th, 2009 at 10:16 am
Noel – you are correct – horticulturalists are key to good landscape design – ideally a horticulturalist would work closely with the designer.
March 19th, 2010 at 8:07 am
[…] You are responsible for some of the most utterly bleak landscapes in the SE of England. For further reading on this subject please refer to my discussion with Noel Kingsbury here and my previous article here. […]
August 4th, 2010 at 2:51 pm
[…] further reading on this subject please refer to my discussion with Noel Kingsbury, and my previous article on Garden […]